If you're shaking your head at the obviousness of homemade versus sit-down or pick-up, understand that we've tried this route before - substituting pizza in a box and pizza made with pre-made crust. Soon after each of these semi-homemade experiments, we were quick to return to our local pizza parlor, where the crust is always thin and perfectly crispy - very New York, very delicious.
Sunday pizza is a lovely tradition and a godsend for busy families gearing up for the week ahead. We grew up with this tradition, and perhaps you did too. In any case, and however you do it, it costs. And kind of a lot, if you really sit down and think about it. Which hardly any of us ever does, me included.
But then one day...I did. I rose my eyebrows (though not as much as when we realized we'd spent $200 on ebooks over the summer - which was not, unfortunately, fraudulent in any way).
Around here, you can get a pie for about $10 each, plus $2 per topping. For argument's sake, let's say you order two pizzas with onions on one and pepperoni on the other (we'll leave out the delivery guy in this scenario).
If you do that every Sunday, you will be spending $24 each week, or $96 each month - $120 if the month has five Sundays - of your hard-earned cash. On pizza! Yikes!
There is an alternative, and it's easy, repeatable, and just as delicious as what you can get at Joey's or Bruno's or Sal's. Maybe more - well, not in the case of Joey's. But very, very close.
Here's how.
On your list will be: two balls of already-made pizza dough ($1.69 each, or $3.38 for two), two cans of pizza sauce ($.99 each, so $1.98 for both), and two bags of shredded cheese ($1.99 each, $3.98 total).
For the pizza that I'm showing here, we did one plain and one with onions (a small yellow one fished out from the back of the fridge, so free) and anchovies ($1.50 each can, so $3 for the two).
So the grand total (not including labor, which is minimal - you'll see) is $12.34. That's roughly half what you'd spend out, plus the added bonus of being in the comfort of your own home, which also has all sorts of benefits when your children are still young, the primary one being that your food doesn't get stuck in your throat from the anxiety of dining out with little ones who perhaps didn't take as long a nap as they needed.
Have I convinced you yet?
Do try. It takes roughly 30 minutes from start to finish (including oven time). And the difference you'll have saved by month's end ($46.64 in a month of four Sundays) will prove very satisfying.
You could, perhaps, take $10 of those saved dollars and buy a new pair of flats for the fall. Just saying...
![]() |
| Thank you, Famous Footwear! |
That's you, Sheena! Please send me an email (raynastpierrehello@gmail.com) with your mailing address so that I can ship your prize promptly!
Have a wonderful week, all! And Happy Columbus Day!


True! And remember there's a point of diminished returns in homemade too. Some things take more money and time to make than you'd think. We do pizza dough and breads but for us, it's not a weekly thing. It's more monthly. Hard to block off those 3 hours when there's so much sunshine..
ReplyDeletePizza night used to be our Saturday night tradition (with a movie night for the kids), but we've recently swapped to Friday as I teach flute after school on Fridays and it just makes life so much easier :) Some weeks we order Dominos but I always have to make at least one pizza myself as the gluten-free boy can't have the dominos ones as they cook the gluten-free bases on the same trays at the gluten ones...but it is so much cheaper (and my gluten free bases are so much nicer!). The two I made on Friday this week ended up costing just over $7 to feed 4 of us for dinner and lunch the next day - ordering from Dominos the week before cost $14 (all NZ dollars obviously!) with one normal pizza and one gluten free base. The shop ones are nice for a treat when I can't be bothered doing it myself, but I much prefer the homemade ones :)
ReplyDeletejasi: You are so right! Your time IS money - good idea for a future post!
ReplyDeleteClare: Gluten-free is a whole thing - a big challenge! Bravo to you for tackling it with such enthusiasm! I'm sure you're version is delish.