This being an election year and all, there's been a lot of talk about American education (Obama and Romney), changing expectations for schools, teachers, and by extension, students and their parents.
In my years as a public high school teacher, I've thought a lot about what makes education "work". Now a parent of a school-age child, I have some new perspectives on what I want from all that time spent away from home.
I now understand - in a way that only the parents of school-going children can - that lioness instinct, whose expression varies from mother to mother, and that sometimes gets (not always fairly) passed on to the teacher.
But, wait. This post is not all In Defense of Teachers. Though I could write that one too. But I'd title it, "In Defense of Teachers" - not what's at the head of this post.
{I'd start that one off reminding everyone that while they should rightly expect teachers to have discretion and wisdom, and to be exemplars and role-models to their students, it's only the crudest among us who ever hold their neighbors' jobs over their heads with the bitter rejoinder, "I'm paying your salary!". I'm so glad we're not like that, aren't you?}
Today, I want to share my thoughts on education as a political issue, and the obvious solution that not one politician - not Obama, not Romney, not Chris Christie at the RNC who kept repeating that easy catchphrase of "holding teachers accountable" - ever says.
It's not making schools compete for money based on standardized test scores. It's not rewriting curriculum; creating a national standard; eliminating teacher tenure; telling teachers to write their lesson plans a certain way; or making them sit in faraway classes for a set number of hours in order to keep their certification. It's not upending everything so that we all have to learn a new way to add.
And it's definitely not leaving it up to bureaucratic movers and shakers who understand lots about what would theoretically work in education and very little about what actually does.
We recognize that things need fixing, but we're not quite sure how to go about it. So when politicians get up on the podium and start firing off their educational rhetoric, we listen. We all agree that there's a problem, we all want a solution, and so we applaud when they dangle their shame-and-blame solution in front of us.
And so it goes.
What I desperately wanted someone to acknowledge this election year is how screwed up our culture has become.
How teachers and schools, once well-respected members of society and revered institutions, have become political pawns.
How our culture teaches that the pinnacle of success is your own reality show, that cheating is merely a means to an end and other unsavory values, a list to which you can probably add.
Once upon a time, parenting was noble. It was respected. Doing it right was a point of pride. Sadly, the entire endeavor has now been diminished to mere corollary, what one does when not doing other things.
If we all simply stood up and acknowledged that our culture has become so time-pressed and values disoriented, we could start to solve some of the problems that manifest during our children's school days.
If we all stood up not just for teachers, but for our hard-working long-commuting families, we might start looking for ways to support - rather than fresh ways to blame - each other.
More than ever, schools are expected to do more with less - less financial support, less moral support. And parents, sitting shell-shocked on Back To School Night, are racking their brains trying to reconcile these more rigorous expectations with the demands of 21st century family life.
We all need a break, but in order to get there, we need some reminders.
I've talked to other mothers (in my group, I am the only teacher) and other teachers (most who are also mothers) and we all agree that as important as teacher accountability, is parental responsibility, the recognition of the home as one's first school.
Did I just state the obvious?
Ladies, let's talk - civilly and in the comments below. I'll see you there.
P.S. Of course you know that I am not saying I ever have been, am, or ever will be a great teacher and/or mother (let alone wife, home cook, daughter, sister, person). I am simply sharing my thoughts, which you might consider misguided, and if so please don't hesitate to tell me. All I ask is that you are polite (I can take almost anything said nicely).
parental responsibility! sometimes you have to state the obvious, because it gets drowned out amid the noise.
ReplyDeletei want my kids to be responsible and well-adjusted and i know education starts in the home and is ongoing. i wonder everyday if i'm doing a "good" job and if they will be equipped to handle school, new friends, the playground, life, etc. am i sheltering them too much? am i exposing them to too much?
my son will be starting kindergarten next year and i am scared shitless. it's hard, man, it's hard!!
Beautifully said Rayna :) It's not just an American problem either, I suspect schools the world over have the same problems and are used in a similar way politically. I completely agree that parental responsibility is probably one of the most important aspects in student achievement (and I don't mean parents doing their kids homework, I can't believe how often that happens!)and all parts of the socio-economic scale are poorly affected by this not happening, for different reasons. Yes, I'm a teacher, but I think it would upset me equally if I weren't, but the reduction in funding for what is perhaps the key area to fund for a successful future society really gets me going. I remember when the NZ government gave millions to the Team NZ campaign (Americans Cup yacht racing...sigh...)and wishing they had spent it on schools instead, especially when our boat's mast broke and the Team NZ boat sunk...Healthcare and Education are the big political issues all over the world, and rightly so, but I wish they actually had experts who had worked in those fields talking and making policies. Right, enough said, I could go on all day :P
ReplyDeleteIt's a sad commentary when you have to state the obvious... and worry about the outcome of stating it.
ReplyDeleteIt's such a viscious cycle... those with less education are less likely to value it, have the means/time to value parenting, and thus they repeat the cycle for their kiddos. How does this ever end!?!?
Amy: I love your candor. It IS scary sending them off, but fear not! You'll get through it and learn to enjoy it. Plus, it's kind of like labor - baby's going to get out into the world no matter what!
ReplyDeleteClare: We could talk for hours. Why, oh why, are you in NZ?
Gina: Thank you for the kind support. It really means a lot! I am quite the chicken with these sorts of posts.
Over here with a shout out from The Minimalist Mom and I just wanted to say how much I appreciated this post and what a great reminder it is to us parents. I'm currently going through a 'reassessment' of our lives (over-burdened, over-extended, over-loaded, ya know?) and this is just another reminder to me, as a mother, that there's too much going on in my children's lives with too much stuff for all of us to be engaged with one another. Thanks for sharing this!
ReplyDeleteThank you, Heather! You can read in the comments that I was a bit nervous about posting this, but now I'm glad that I did!
ReplyDeleteI totally hear everything you are saying! I'm working on some upcoming posts addressing the very things you're talking about. I have found that living simpler is a journey (the destination is ever-elusive), but there's joy in that as well!
Best to you...